Standardization in Hydroacoustic Assessments: Fundament or Folly?

Monday, August 20, 2012: 1:15 PM-5:15 PM
Ballroom A (RiverCentre)
Hydroacoustic sampling is a common and useful tool for the assessment of aquatic and marine organisms.  Technological and theoretical improvements are consistently occurring, but comparability of data from different environments is often limited (or perceived to be limited) by differences in equipment, sampling, and data analysis techniques.  While some effort has been made to identify factors that impart incomparability and to develop/adopt standards to minimize differences, uncertainties remain.  We propose a symposium to review and synthesize the need for and importance of standardization in hydroacoustic assessment.  Our primary objective is to identify areas in which standardization efforts remain necessary and critical to improve comparability of research.  We invite presentations from aquatic and marine environments that compare and contrast multiple methods of assessing organisms and communities using hydroacoustics.  Examples of topics include comparisons of frequencies, equipment, software, deployment techniques, and density apportionment to species or size groups.
Organizers:
David M. Warner , Daniel L. Yule and Patrick M. Kocovsky
Moderators:
David M. Warner , Daniel L. Yule and Patrick M. Kocovsky
 
M-A-17
Acoustical Estimate of Fish Distribution in the Three Gorges Reservoir, China (Withdrawn)
1:45 PM
Advantages and Challenges to Standardizing Fishery Sonar Surveys in Coral Reef Ecosystems
J. Christopher Taylor, NOAA National Ocean Service; Laura Kracker, NOAA National Ocean Service

2:00 PM
Field Calibrations in Practice: Results from Three Years of Weekly Acoustic Surveys of Nearshore Fish Populations in Lake Ontario
Christopher W.D. Gurshin, Normandeau Associates, Inc.; Matthew P. Balge, Normandeau Associates, Inc.; Sean J. Maxwell, Normandeau Associates, Inc.; Scott Schanke, Normandeau Associates

2:15 PM
Performance Assessment of a Draft European Standard for Sampling Lake Fish Using Hydroacoustics
Ian Winfield, Centre for Ecology & Hydrology; Jon Hateley, Environment Agency

2:30 PM
Standard Operating Procedures for Great Lakes Hydroacoustics: Importance of Recommendations Across Lakes
Patrick M. Kocovsky, U.S.G.S. Great Lakes Science Center; Lars G. Rudstam, Cornell Biological Field Station, Cornell University; Daniel L. Yule, U.S.G.S. Great Lakes Science Center; David M. Warner, USGS Great Lakes Science Center; Ted Schaner, Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources; Bernard Pientka, Vermont Department of Fish and Wildlife; John Deller, Fairport Fisheries Research Station; Holly Waterfield, State University of New York; Larry Witzel, Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources; Patrick J. Sullivan, Cornell University

2:45 PM
Didson Assessment of American Shad Approaching a Hydroelectric Dam
Ann B. Grote, University of Maine; Joseph Zydlewski, U.S. Geological Survey, Maine Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit; Michael M. Bailey, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

3:00 PM
Monday PM Break


3:30 PM
Evaluation of Dual Frequency Data to Differentiate Species in the Great Lakes
David M. Warner, USGS Great Lakes Science Center; Timothy P. O'Brien, U.S.G.S. Great Lakes Science Center; Steve Farha, U.S.G.S. Great Lakes Science Center; Jeffrey S. Schaeffer, U.S. Geological Survey; Lars G. Rudstam, Cornell Biological Field Station, Cornell University

3:45 PM
Comparison of Methods for Estimating Atlantic Cod Biomass from Acoustic and Trawl Surveys
Christopher W.D. Gurshin, Normandeau Associates, Inc.; W. Huntting Howell, University of New Hampshire; J. Michael Jech, NOAA/NEFSC

4:00 PM
Use of Classification Trees to Apportion Acoustic Targets to Species: Application to the 2011 Lake-Wide Acoustic and Midwater Trawl Survey of Lake Superior
Daniel L. Yule, U.S.G.S. Great Lakes Science Center; Jean V. Adams, U. S. Geological Survey; Thomas Hrabik, University of Minnesota, Duluth; Mark R. Vinson, U.S. Geological Survey; Zeb Woiak, U.S.G.S. Great Lakes Science Center; Tyler Ahrenstorff, University of Minnesota

4:15 PM
Evaluating Approaches for Apportioning Acoustic Density to Species Using Simulated Great Lakes Fish Communities
Daniel L. Yule, U.S.G.S. Great Lakes Science Center; Jean V. Adams, U. S. Geological Survey; David M. Warner, USGS Great Lakes Science Center; Thomas Hrabik, University of Minnesota, Duluth; Patrick Kocovsky, US Geological Survey; Brian Weidel, USGS Great Lakes Science Center; Lars G. Rudstam, Cornell Biological Field Station, Cornell University; Patrick J. Sullivan, Cornell University

 
Species Apportionment of Lake Superior Hydroacoustic Targets Using Midwater Trawl Catch Proportions and Classification and Regression Trees (Withdrawn)
See more of: Symposium Proposals