Protecting Fish at Cooling Water Intakes: New Rules and Science-based Solutions (Symposium)

Thursday, August 25, 2016: 8:00 AM-4:20 PM
Chouteau A (Sheraton at Crown Center)
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) released a final rule implementing 316(b) of the Clean Water Act on August 15, 2014. This regulatory action targets reduction in mortality associated with the impingement and entrainment of fish and shellfish at cooling water intakes, and affects over 1,000 facilities (power plants, pulp and paper mills, iron mills, chemical plants, oil & gas facilities) throughout the U.S. that use cooling water. Industries, federal and state regulatory and resource agencies, non-governmental organizations and the public are now faced with the challenge of implementing this rule. This symposium will present the latest information on:
  1. technologies for protecting fish and shellfish at cooling water intakes – including traveling water screens, velocity caps, intake velocity, barrier nets, behavioral systems, closed-cycle cooling systems, and other methods for reducing, excluding or collecting and returning fish and shellfish to source waterbodies.
  2. methods for characterizing impingement and entrainment and for determining the performance of technologies. 
  3. methods for economic analysis to determine the cost-benefit for compliance activities.
  4. challenges and science-based solutions to rule implementation.

Moderators:
Terry E. Cheek, Ronald Heun, Chuck Coutant, William Dey and Douglas A. Dixon
Chairs:
Jon Black and Daniel Giza
Organizers:
Terry E. Cheek, Ronald Heun, Chuck Coutant, William Dey, Douglas A. Dixon, Jon Black and Daniel Giza
8:00 AM
Collaborative 316b Study of Seven Power Plants on the Ohio River, Year 1 Results Jason Rager, EA Engineering, Science & Technology; Joe Vondruska, EA Engineering, Science, and Technology; Greg Seegert, EA Engineering, Science, and Technology; Douglas A. Dixon, Electric Power Research Institute
8:20 AM
Inside out: A Comparison of Entrainment Sampling in-Plant Vs Offshore Eric Miller, MBC Applied Environmental Sciences
8:40 AM
Internet-Based Larval Fish and Egg Taxonomic Key Resource for Freshwater and Marine Environments Christopher Cieciek, LimnoTech; Nancy A. Auer, Michigan Technological University
9:00 AM
Molecular Method Applications to Support Entrainment Study Evaluations Douglas Bradley, LimnoTech; Robert Hanner, University of Guelph; Amanda Naaum, University of Guelph; Jennifer Daley, LimnoTech; Paul Patrick, LimnoTech
9:20 AM
Thursday Morning Break
9:40 AM
Comparison of Survival of Fish Eggs and Larvae Via Collection and Transfer By Fine Mesh Traveling Screens Vs. through-Plant Entrainment Survival Gary Thorn, Consolidated Edison; Brooks Fost, ASA Analysis&Communication; William Dey, ASA Analysis & Communication; Douglas A. Dixon, Electric Power Research Institute
10:00 AM
Multi-Model Inference for Estimating Entrainment Survival John Young, ASA Analysis & Communication, Inc; Brooks Fost, ASA Analysis&Communication; William Dey, ASA Analysis & Communication, Inc
10:20 AM
316(b) Applications: Thoughts from a Regulator on Study Plans Sean Ramach, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
10:40 AM
Comparison Between the Final 2014 EPA Phase II Rule and New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Commissioner's Policy - 52 in Implementing the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Colleen Kimble, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation; Chuck Nieder, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
11:00 AM
Endangered Species Act Case Studies Related to Clean Water Act 316(b) Harriet Nash, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
11:20 AM
Discussion 1
11:40 AM
Thursday Lunch Break
1:00 PM
Coordination for Implementation of the 316(b) Rule for Two Utilities on the Missouri River Dan Bigbee, EA Engineering, Science, and Technology, Inc., PBC
1:40 PM
Non-Use Benefits: 800 Lb. Gorilla or Gentle Pussy Cat? William Dey, ASA Analysis & Communication, Inc
2:00 PM
Facilitating Clean Water Act 316(b) Rule-Required Peer Review of 122.21(r) Reports Radhika de Silva, HDR; John Burnett, HDR; Mark Bailey, HDR
2:20 PM
Laboratory Traveling Water Screen Optimization Evaluations Douglas A. Dixon, Electric Power Research Institute; Stephen V. Amaral, Alden Research Laboratory, Inc.; Timothy Grant, Alden Research Laboratory, INC.; Daniel Giza, Alden Research Laboratory, Inc.
3:00 PM
Thursday Afternoon Break
3:20 PM
Technical Developments in Fish Exclusion & Debris Barriers Andy Peters, Pacific Netting Products; J.S. Poulton, Ontario Power Generation
3:40 PM
Utilizing Skimmer or Curtain Walls to Reduce Entrainment at Cooling Water Intake Structures Jonathan Black, HDR Engineering Inc.; Michael Abney, Duke Energy Environmental Center; John A.D. Burnett, HDR Engineering Inc.; Douglas A. Dixon, Electric Power Research Institute
4:00 PM
Discussion 2
See more of: Symposium Entries